Earl Michael Simmons became a central figure in the Cayla Kelley Earl Simmons case after investigators identified him as a suspect in the January 6, 2024 killing of Cayla Kelley. He was later connected by investigators to a second homicide involving Eddie Matthews, who was killed in New Orleans only a few hours after Kelley.
According to the investigation described by Homicide Squad New Orleans, detectives began focusing on Simmons after examining information provided during the early investigation and reviewing surveillance footage from the area. The footage reportedly placed Simmons with Kelley around the time of her death.
Simmons was arrested on January 18, 2024, and was charged with two counts of second-degree murder. The charges related to the deaths of Kelley and Matthews. However, these remain allegations unless and until they are proven in court.
Table of Contents
How Were Cayla Kelley and Eddie Matthews Connected?
The connection between Cayla Kelley and Eddie Matthews is one of the most important parts of the case.
Kelley was killed at approximately 6:13 p.m. on January 6, 2024, according to contemporary reporting. Matthews was killed later that evening at approximately 10:22 p.m. The shootings therefore happened only a few hours apart.
At the beginning, investigators were dealing with two different homicide scenes. The significance of the second case became clearer when investigators compared physical evidence from both locations.
According to the later television coverage, shell casings from the two scenes were connected through ballistic testing. The result reportedly indicated that the same firearm had been used in both killings.
What Evidence Led Police to Earl Simmons?
The investigation appears to have developed through several stages rather than one sudden discovery.
Detectives first had to establish what happened to Kelley. They then worked to understand who had been around her and what might have happened shortly before the shooting. Surveillance cameras became particularly useful because they could provide information that witnesses might not have seen or remembered.
The television account of the investigation says Detective Walter Edmond reviewed surveillance footage and found material that placed Simmons at the scene with Kelley. An arrest warrant was subsequently issued.
The investigation then gained another major piece of information when ballistic testing reportedly connected the firearm evidence from Kelley’s killing to Matthews’ death.
Cayla Kelley Earl Simmons Update: Where Is the Case Now?
The most recent publicly available reporting I found continues to describe Earl Michael Simmons as awaiting trial rather than reporting a final murder conviction or sentence. A recent case-focused report states that he remains behind bars while awaiting trial.
There does not appear to be a confirmed public report in the sources reviewed here announcing a completed trial, conviction, or sentence in the Kelley and Matthews case.
That makes the wording of a Cayla Kelley Earl Simmons update particularly important. Readers may come across social-media posts or older true-crime articles that describe Simmons as the killer. Those descriptions can go beyond what has been legally established.
How Homicide Squad New Orleans Covered the Cayla Kelley Case
The case received renewed public attention through A&E’s crime documentary series Homicide Squad New Orleans.
The Kelley and Matthews investigation was featured in Season 1, Episode 2, titled “In Cold Blood.” The episode was released on January 2, 2025, and has a runtime of about 41 minutes.
The episode follows Detective Walter Edmond as he investigates Kelley’s killing. It also follows Detective Jameson Diesburg’s investigation into Matthews’ death and shows how the two investigations eventually become connected through ballistic evidence.
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| January 6, 2024 | Cayla Kelley was fatally shot in New Orleans. |
| January 6, 2024 | Eddie Matthews was fatally shot several hours later. |
| Investigation period | Detectives reviewed surveillance and physical evidence. |
| Ballistic breakthrough | Investigators reportedly connected firearm evidence from both killings. |
| January 18, 2024 | Earl Michael Simmons was arrested and charged with two counts of second-degree murder. |
| January 2, 2025 | Homicide Squad New Orleans aired “In Cold Blood,” featuring the case. |
| Latest available reporting | Simmons continues to be described in recent reporting as awaiting trial. |
Key Facts About Cayla Kelley and Earl Simmons
A few details are especially important for anyone researching the case:
- Cayla Kelley was 27 when she was killed.
- Kelley and Eddie Matthews were killed on the same night in New Orleans.
- The two shootings happened only several hours apart.
- Investigators reportedly used surveillance footage to identify Simmons as a suspect.
- Ballistic evidence reportedly connected the weapon used in the two killings.
- Simmons was arrested on January 18, 2024.
- He was charged with two counts of second-degree murder.
- The case was later featured on Homicide Squad New Orleans.
- Recent reporting still describes Simmons as awaiting trial.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who Was Cayla Kelley?
Cayla Kelley was a 27-year-old beautician and makeup artist from New Orleans who was fatally shot on January 6, 2024. Her death became part of a larger homicide investigation after detectives connected it with the killing of Eddie Matthews.
What Happened to Cayla Kelley?
Kelley was found suffering from multiple gunshot wounds in New Orleans on January 6, 2024. She was pronounced dead at the scene, and police began investigating her killing.
Who Is Earl Michael Simmons?
Earl Michael Simmons is the man who was arrested and charged with two counts of second-degree murder in connection with the deaths of Cayla Kelley and Eddie Matthews.
Was Earl Simmons Convicted?
The latest publicly available reporting reviewed for this article does not report a completed murder conviction or sentence. Recent coverage describes Simmons as awaiting trial.
How Were Cayla Kelley and Eddie Matthews Connected?
Investigators reportedly discovered that ballistic evidence from the two crime scenes matched, indicating that the same firearm was used in both killings.
Final Thoughts
The Cayla Kelley Earl Simmons update is ultimately a story about how investigators connected two killings that initially appeared to be separate. Kelley was killed on January 6, 2024, and Eddie Matthews was killed later that same night. Surveillance footage and ballistic evidence reportedly played major roles in connecting the investigations and identifying Earl Michael Simmons as the suspect.
Simmons was arrested and charged with two counts of second-degree murder, but the distinction between an accusation and a conviction remains essential. Based on the latest publicly available reporting reviewed here, he is still described as awaiting trial.
Read More: angie lassman husband
